« Articles

Neutral Spotlight – Hon. Sarah L. Deneke (Ret.)

With over 80 distinguished Neutrals—including retired judges and seasoned attorneys—serving Virginia, Washington, D.C., and Maryland, The McCammon Group is excited to continue our “Neutral Spotlight” series. This ongoing feature highlights the exceptional expertise, diverse experiences, and unique backgrounds of our Neutrals. Through these spotlights, we offer a closer look at the professionals who are committed to delivering fair, effective, and innovative dispute resolution services. Join us as we showcase the individuals who contribute to The McCammon Group’s reputation as a trusted leader in alternative dispute resolution.

  1. If you had to describe yourself in three words, what would they be? Reliable, steady, and committed.
  2. If you could pick a superpower, what would it be and why?  Time travel. So much to explore. I want to be able to come back, though.
  3. If you could swap lives with any person for a day, who would it be and why?  Melinda French Gates. She is wicked smart, unbelievably rich, avoids publicity, and gives away tons of money.
  4. How has your experience as a judge shaped your approach to mediation?  It taught me patience, preparation, and that both parties usually have valid points.
  5. What qualities do you think are essential for someone to be an effective Neutral? Calm demeanor, ability to adapt to different people and factual situations.
  6. How do you handle situations where both parties seem unwilling to compromise?  I try to remove the emotion and carefully explain their options. I will explain the foundation of mediation again and ask why they wanted to participate and what their expectations were. Then we will discuss how to get there, if possible.
  7. What do you enjoy most about being a Neutral?  Not having to make the decisions and the satisfaction of settling a case.
  8. What do you think the biggest misconception about mediation is?  That arguments matter more than documented facts.
  9. What advice would you give to lawyers about preparing for mediations?  Prepare your clients for realistic expectations and sometimes difficult conversations.
  10. What’s the best piece of advice you’ve ever received?  Never judge a person or a case by first impressions.

    The Honorable Sarah L. Deneke joined The McCammon Group in 2025 after seventeen years of distinguished judicial service.  Most recently, she served thirteen years on the 15th Judicial Circuit Court with one term as Chief Judge.  Prior to that, she served four years on the General District Court. Before her judicial service, Judge Deneke enjoyed a successful career in private practice and served as an Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney for Fairfax County and as a Deputy Commonwealth’s Attorney for Spotsylvania and Stafford Counties. Among her many credentials, she is a former Faculty Member of the Virginia State Bar’s Professionalism Course and a former recipient of the Assistant Commonwealth’s Attorney of the Year Award. Judge Deneke now brings this record of dedication and accomplishment to The McCammon Group to serve the mediation, arbitration, judge pro tempore, and special master needs of lawyers and litigants throughout the Commonwealth.

WHAT LAWYERS AND LITIGANTS ARE SAYING:

  • "The mediator was essential to injecting reality into discussions."

  • "A truly excellent job; patient, thorough and helpful in evaluating options."

  • "Scheduling was easy, prompt and efficient."

  • "The mediator was extremely prepared, compassionate, and determined to assist the parties with reaching a resolution."

  • "We were able to settle a highly contentious case after years of litigation just a few weeks before trial."

  • "Great communication and easy to deal with. Excellent all around."

  • "The mediator was fair and understood how to convey the weakness of a case without being judgmental."

  • "I have always been favorably impressed by the Neutrals at The McCammon Group."

  • "The mediator handled a very difficult mediation with patience and humor."

  • "Extraordinary skill and persistence in successfully mediating a very difficult case."

  • "Very efficient and courteous."

  • "Sometimes the human side of these cases leaves the practical side and they seem impossible to settle. Your "never give up" attitude carried the day."

  • "You have rendered invaluable service to me and my clients in the past, and we will continue to call upon you in the future when the need for a highly-skilled professional mediator arises."

  • "The depth and quality of the available mediators is exceptional."

  • "It is always great to use McCammon instead of litigation!"

  • "The quality of your panel members allows choice and comfort in the knowledge that your matter will be fully and fairly heard and resolved."